MEDICAL MALPRACTICE ATTORNEYS
NEW YORK CITY
Call Medical malpractice Attorney NYC (212) 861-5000

Call For Free Consultation

Pain and Suffering “Caps” Can Be Unjust to the Victim, and a Windfall for the Negligent

Steven E. North, Esq. and Laurence M. Deutsch, Esq.


A recent article on WebMed.com indicates that medical error is the nation’s third leading cause of death, right behind cancer and heart disease. More than a quarter of a million people die each year in the U.S. because of medical error.

And yet in many states, no matter how egregious an error, no matter how profoundly a person might endure months or years of excruciating or life-changing limitations because of an error, the wronged patient cannot claim more than $250,000. Is that fair compensation for a person who was blinded or otherwise maimed by medical malpractice?

There are currently proposals before the New York State Legislature to mirror the practices of those states that impose the arbitrary of $250,000 cap for all “pain and suffering” damages.

“Pain and suffering” is a somewhat hackneyed phrase. But it is the legal term for a common-sense category of damages, e.g., any damage to a person for loss of life’s enjoyments. It does not necessarily mean “the “ouch” element but, rather, all of the experiences that render a person unable enjoy the benefits of life to which he or she otherwise would have or should have been entitled to.

For example, if an unemployed woman who attends to her home and family loses a limb (or two!) because of medical malpractice, she would be relegated to living the rest of her life in that impaired state. In such a case, what is $250,000 against her loss of independence, inability to swim, run, drive, or enjoy the many activities of living?

And, consider fairness between tort victims. If medical malpractice damages are artificially limited to well below the actual loss by a “pain and suffering cap,” there would be tremendous inequity, for example, between someone suffering the same losses as the result of an automobile accident caused by a negligent driver. Such an automotive injury would be evaluated in terms of multiple millions of dollars for pain and suffering, but a person suffering the same injury from medical malpractice would be unable to obtain any significant compensation.

Consider also, if a cap is unfair to the victim of real and severe malpractice, then who benefits from it? If the party responsible for the malpractice pays less for the injuries than he or she should, and the injured person receives less than he or she should, isn’t this a double injustice?

Back to Medical Malpractice Attorney NYC

Medical Malpractice Verdicts

For Our Clients We Recovered More Than

$200 million

In Verdicts & Settlements

Medical Malpractice Expertise

North & Deutsch has a long history not only of understanding and presenting medical evidence successfully, but also of understanding and presenting the real-world impact of medical malpractice on the life of an affected person and his or her family. Our attorneys have deep expertise and a network of world-class experts to help us determine whether your case does, in fact, demonstrate malpractice.

Medical Malpractice Case Results
  • Obstetrical Medical Malpractice
    $26 Million

    Obstetrical Malpractice

  • Vascular Medical Malpractice
    $15.7 Million

    Vascular Surgery Malpractice

  • Cardiology Medical Malpractice
    $14.8 Million

    Cardiology Malpractice

Medical Malpractice Clients Testimonials

We thank you for your Negotiating tenacity... The award was so much more than either Denise or I anticipated... Read more.

Sally and Denise

Thank you for your responsiveness and professionalism... Read more.

Dr. B

Thank you for everything! I really appreciate your help and kindness... Read more.

Mrs. M.

Meet our Medical Malpractice Attorneys
Medical Malpractice Attorney Steven E. North from NYC
Steven E. North

Specialist in Cases Involving Significant Damages • Listed in Best Lawyers • Listed in Who’s Who • Commentator, Court T.V., Eyewitness News, Talk News T.V. • Contributing Author, New York Law Journal Author of Numerous Publications • Faculty Chairman, Continuing Legal Education Programs • Trial Lawyer and Bar Association Committees

Medical Malpractice Attorney Laurence M. Deutsch from NYC
Laurence M. Deutsch

1988, New York and U.S. District Court, Northern, Southern, Eastern and Western Districts of New York. Union College, Schenectady, B.A., magna cum laude, 1984 Phi Beta Kappa; University of Chicago Law School, J.D., 1987

Medical Malpractice Attorney Awards
Medical Malpractice Attorney Awards Medical Malpractice top ten Attorney Awards Medical Malpractice Attorney Awards
Top 20 verdicts Awards Medical Malpractice super lawyer Awards
Medical Malpractice best Attorney Awards

FREE MEDICAL MALPRACTICE CONSULTATION BY NEW YORK ATTORNEY

Receive a complimentary consultation from one of our experienced attorneys.